Silnylon vs silpoly.

Silnylon vs silpoly 1. December 13, 2020. 6 oz from RBTR. Especially with the discount. Silpoly is pretty much the same thing as silnylon — just trade out the nylon yarn for polyester. I’m all silpoly or dyneema now. Silnylon, silpoly, and Dynema are all very similar with slightly different characteristics. For the latter you can use sil on the sil side. 3oz SilNylon, 0. My old silny tent would absorb water, and it took 3x as long to dry in the sun and wind than my brothers silpoly. 0lbf and they seemed like they were really trying to jam that nail through fairly hard in the last one, and the SilNylon is listed as having much stronger tear strength in the specs sheet than all the Cuben fibers. Mar 11, 2023 · Siliconized nylon, more commonly called silnylon, is a waterproof fabric used to make tents by many smaller manufacturers including Tarptent, Mountain Laurel Designs, and Hilleberg which specialize in making ultralight backpacking gear or expedition-grade tents. I keep seeing claims of 'our silnylon is superior', but I have yet to find a sample that really is superior. Being square makes many different configurations easily put up and figured out which is nice. Makes me both impressed but skeptical about the silnylon version. UltraTNT weighs . 6 can be sourced at RSBTR and Rockywoods carries a 7D Sil one side and PU the other. Mar 22, 2019 · Soo, back to your question. Is there a significant difference between the performance of sil-nylon and sil-poly, especially in arid regions? Thanks! Fabric: 30D Silpoly. Nov 3, 2023 · 2. More typically used as basic rain wear. I get that the 20D Silpoly is lighter, is the 30D silnylon more durable? Oct 6, 2024 · Ich dachte mehr oder weniger dasselbe, aber Xavier konnte das Verhalten von Silnylon 20D im Vergleich zu Silpoly 30D in Bezug auf die Wasseraufnahme testen. Be it silnylon or silpoly. The silnylon is fine, but I use a polycro footprint (about 50 g). I haven't personally made anything with the silpoly yet, but all the feedback I've gotten on the silpoly has been very positive. 8 reviews for Stash Jacket. Silnylon is more tear resistant than silpoly and exists in larger selection of fabrics. Silpoly Field Test Analysis <p>In this episode we go over the finding of our recent tent fabric field test. 133 Silnylon vs. Besides, DCF is trivially patched. I'm about to order a Superfly from Warbonnet and before I bug Brandon I thought I would ask all of you. I think I’m going to go with 20D 1. No 10D or 15D silnylons to be found anywhere though. 20D and 30D silnylons can be had from 5 or 6 sources. I have tested Asian fabrics which are nylon 6. 1 OSY stuff that Dutch and RSBTR use. I can simply patch small punctures or leaks then seam-seal them. Imo silpoly is a better jacket material as it doesn’t soak up water like silnylon does. Silny is just a bad option for wet and humid climates. Aug 10, 2023 · Silnylon has long been favored for its decent waterproofing and relative affordability. Silnylon absorbs moisture which causes the material to relax, so it looses tautness after setup. Silpoly is less likely to stretch and sag when it rains. 6 with a silicone coating. Mar 31, 2016 · The silpoly vs silnylon durability I mean) Anyhow I really like both of these tarps and I think a 10x10 size encompasses almost anything you want it need to do with a tarp. also, factor in the 0. I currently have a membrane silpoly tarp that has one small tear and I fear for it's lifespan, especially around my boys. Silpoly, short for silicone-coated polyester, is another waterproof material used in outdoor gear material. It did not weigh much and had dried out for the most part by the time that we packed up at 9am. Their DST tarp has held up well for me on a lot of trips too. The goal is to present a framework that allows you to select a shelter type for a particular environment and hiking style. Jul 9, 2018 · Silnylon: Less resistant to UV rays, heavier weight to carry both dry and wet, takes longer to "dry out", will need adjustment once saturated Silpoly-Not as durable as Silnylon due to lower weight of materials, more difficult to sew, less resistant to embers/sparks Silpoly vs silnylon tent test Silnylon may absorb more water but it's not like a towel, it's waterproof. However, UltraTNT’s weight advantage makes it a superior choice for those seeking to minimize pack weight without compromising on performance. Apr 7, 2024 · Silnylon und Silpoly sind zwei beliebte Optionen, die jeweils ihre eigenen Vor- und Nachteile haben. Le poids serait quasiment identique, avec seulement 30grammes en plus pour le 40D silpoly. Jul 22, 2024 · I've had the Tents from the 1. runterrutschen. So these are very similar, but what is the difference between the base core fabrics of nylon and polyester? The core difference is that nylon is hydrophilic, which means it absorbs water which means in lengthened rainfall the fabric tends to start to sag and get heavier. On the other hand, Silpoly fabric’s excellent UV resistance promises longevity and protection against sun damage, an important consideration for frequent campers. Much easier to work with along with the stretch and UV advantages. Jul 28, 2015 · I’ve read enough “high quality silnylon” threads here to understand that ExtremTextil’s fabric should meet its rating but would love confirmation or advice from folks with experience. I got offered a good deal on a lightly used sil-nylon tarp. Like, I'd trust a 20d silnylon that Ron tested and selected against, e. That is a nylon layer, which is coated with silicone on both sides. Dyneema has a lower melting point than silnylon, so in a hot tent application ember holes will be bigger. 9 or so, and most is around 1. 5' tall] from the Sil poly about 8-10 years ago. Joined Jul 2, 2020 Messages 50. Feb 11, 2023 · You can’t find 15D silnylon either, at least not in the States. With tarps, you need a taught pitch. 13. The $140 MLD Grace tarp is a Solo in SilPoly and 255g. Jun 8, 2023 · Like Dyneema, UltraTNT is what is known as a composite fabric. May 11, 2023 · I’m using silpoly 1. I found hearsay on backpackinglight that silnylon can vary from 1200mm to 3500mm just based on process, without too much change in weight. Spec sheet screenshot below. Nov 16, 2020 · Cuben Fiber vs Silnylon vs Silpoly. It weighs 1. The silicone increases the tear strength and makes the material water repellent or waterproof. Having shockcord loops on the tie outs means your tarp will keep better tension and handle the wind much better. Thoughts on silnylon vs silpoly for both a camp tarp & hammock tarp? The cost difference is negligible but from a strength, waterproofness and ease of sewing does one hold an advantage over the other? Silpoly is going to be less durable, BUT it starts out lighter and won't hold water like silnylon will. Apr 26, 2024 · On the other hand silnylon/silpoly can hold a lot of water and of course that means a far heavier shelter to carry around, at least until you get a chance to maybe stop and let it dry out. 2 Minuten. I only have one silpoly shelter and it's much smaller, a Durston X mid 1. Thread: silnylon vs. A couple of disadvantages of DCF that you haven't mentioned. Silpoly doesn't absorb as much water. Advantages and disadvantages of each material for tents and tarps. Apr 16, 2025 · There is a mismatch between weight and price on the Mountain Laurel Design Grace Duo. After a rain, I can pop/shake the silpoly and be on my way nearly completely dry. The darker the fabric, the better it resists UV damage. While a DCF shelter will be lighter weight (the larger the shelters, the bigger the weight difference) than one made with silnylon, it will be bulkier to pack. So on balance, I suspect that Jon is right and silpoly is the greener fabric. vs. I will use for comparison our Silnylon , and the MTN Sil from Ripstop since it has a similar coating as ours and SilPoly from Ripstop. Taffeta only goes down to 2. Plenty of silnylons, especially the thinner ones, are just as if not more slippery. Apr 2, 2023 · Finally, ( and I quote Xavier ) silnylon has advantages that silpoly does not have : it is more resistant to drilling due to its elasticity because the fibers tend to resume their places after a perforation, and this elasticity makes it possible to obtain a better tension of the shelter, what I can also confirm with my 2 shelters in 20D silpoly Jul 20, 2015 · Not trying to hijack your thread but it seems like a similar discussion. , I have not seen any functional difference between the two materials under normal parameters (camping, storms, etc. Personally, I’d probably pick the cheaper or lighter option of a the two. So what is a silnylon tent and what is a silpoly tent? This is about coating used on the tent fabric. So feel free to offer feedback on silnylon if you think it overall has an edge on either of these Oct 24, 2021 · The most significant cause of tent life is UV, which breaks down fabric fibre molecules and subsequently pulverises and breaks them. Nylon, however, is hydrophilic, meaning that it absorbs water over time. 5 ' x 7. 8oz for 20d vs 11. I found this video from Zpacks, they poke a nail through 1. Many pyramid tarp manufacturers offer their shelters in several fabric options, including Dyneema DCF and silnylon. 9 oz) silpoly is available but it’s pretty weak stuff. These look awesome too. He’s done a lot of practical testing, and his unambiguous advice is to go for the silpoly. Nov 9, 2016 · Tarps have come up quite often lately. 1. Mar 30, 2023 · 4: Some 20d silnylon stretches way less than some 20d silpoly, even when wet. Polyester as a fabric does no absorb water, but at the same denier it is not as strong or abrasion resistant as Nylon. The stretch is only noticeable long term in tarps too. Weights for 4 meters of fabric are 7. It’s a pain in the butt to dry out compared to silpoly. , a 30d silnylon from a NatureHike tent. This fabric is becoming more popular because it costs about the same as silnylon but doesn’t absorb as much water Jul 2, 2020 · Silnylon VS Silpoly. Silpoly is a waterproof fabric made from polyester, while silnylon is a lightweight nylon material with a silicone coating that adds water resistance to the fabric. 1 oz/yd 2 prior to coating (about 1. 5' die, 7. It seemed surprising to me though since the 1. Silnylon: Key differences and considerations for backpackers Dec 2, 2022 · Silpoly vs Silnylon for Tarps & Tents – Pros & Cons (Overview) Hiking , Backpacking , Camping / By Mikkel Skødt Damsgaard / December 2, 2022 When it comes to choosing materials for tarps and tents, different materials have distinct advantages and disadvantages, and deciding which trade-offs to make is necessary for selecting the “right” one. PU4000 would be $7. COST: $60 WEIGHT: 1. Probably because "Winter Is Coming". Both of them pack down small, are cheap, and need seam sealing. Not sure how to seam seal the former, nor which SMD is using. I’d look at the wildgeardesigns pentatarp or tipik pioulou, both in silpoly so water won’t be an issue. While silnylon and silpoly are traditional woven fabrics coated in liquid silicone, UltraTNT and Dyneema are laminated. Here are some of the differences: Silnylon vs. Also, a lot hinges on your use case. You can get silpoly that is 90% as strong as the same weight of nylon, where since nylon loses 10% strength when wet the poly can be just as strong in the field on day #1, and then the nylon further weakens over time from greater UV degradation. I strongly prefer silpoly in general, but could see the argument for silnylon on, say, a duomid used for 4 seasons. Black and very dark blue are the best for both silpoly and silnylon. . I suspect silnylon is as well. Sep 18, 2019 · Cuben Fiber vs Silnylon vs Silpoly. durability, I'd imagine. 6oz silpoly from RSBTR knowing I was going to use it in harsh environments and wanted more strength. You have to go slow. In terms of tear strength, the pullouts, stitching, etc. Actually, that's four out of five, but I'll let Meat Loaf do the selling on purchasing a SilPoly Superfly: Meatloaf to GingeGirl about SilPoly(cue the music, please) "Baby we can talk all night Aug 15, 2021 · Hi all, After reading your discussions about polyester vs nylon (thank you for those), I’m still planning on using silnylon for my next tent and was pretty settled on RBTR’s 1. Car ce polyester enduit de silicone serait naturellement plus imperméable et résistant aux UV que le silnylon, chouchou des industriels depuis les années 70. Thread Tools. Jun 18, 2019 · Silpoly -vs- Silnylon when wet No adjustments were made since the initial setup about 20 hours ago. SilNylon stretches and wets out or soaks in some water when it rains which requires the use of some shock cord guy lines to keep the tarp taught. I cannot imagine either getting shredded at all even on granite. In SilPoly it is 315g and $165. Especially since floors are commonly the limiting factor for the entire shelter - you're potentially paying $50 to halve the lifespan of your expensive DCF shelter for a mere 1oz savings. 1 oz Silpoly PU4000 (1. Aug 28, 2020 · The conventional wisdom is that nylon is substantially stronger, but that consensus seems to have started from unfair comparisons that pit a silnylon vs a PU poly (where the sil tilts the playing field towards nylon) and thus isn’t nearly as true for silnylon vs silpoly (or even sil versus other PU formulations like PEU). If the colors and shades are exactly the same, then polyester does edge out nylon some. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. ) and is said to pick up less water weight than the nylon. Oct 14, 2020 · I sold it because I think silnylon kinda sucks. I do carry both DCF patch/tape and silnylon patch in my repair kit. Nylon 6. I think if there was a silpoly version (single wall, sub 30oz), I would be all over that. 2. I have looked. But I’ve spent many grueling hours looking for the right silpoly for a tent, from all conceivable sources, including tent makers and fabric dealers in Europe and Asia, all to no avail; so thought an inquiry here might get me off the dime where I’m stuck. I use a WB Blackbird XLC. 3 after) and is used both for rainflys and floors. Feb 19, 2023 · For most brands, the differences between silpoly and silnylon are negligible; most use 20-denier or 30-denier fabrics that are about 1. Silpoly is not as light as DCF, but it packs down to a smaller size than DCF and silnylon. Ähnlich wie Wilbo stelle ich fest, dass bei DCF (und Ultra) mehr Wasser am Stoff hängen bleibt, während die Regentropfen bei Silnylon und Silpoly besser abperlen bzw. hutzelbein. silnylon stretches and sags, silpoly does not. 1 silnylon or 1. I have a 9. If you don't catch it a rip will keep going. Jan 29, 2016 · If it were half the cost of SilNylon, I *might* do more with it simply because it is lighter. Bonding Silpoly / Silnylon tarp If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. Er stellte zwei völlig identische Unterkünfte, eine aus Silnylon 20D, die andere aus Silpoly 30D, unter einen 6-stündigen Dauerregen. The current silpoly we carry has a slightly lower waterproof rating than the silnylon, but other than that, the silpoly seems to be pulling ahead. - Size is 70"x108" (5. 1 oz (1. It is less tear resistant than silnylon. Coated on the outside with silicone and on the inside with polyurethane (PU), this maintenance-free rain jacket won’t wet out like much more Silpoly Solo Tarp: These are our solo tarps made from lightweight 100% waterproof silpoly fabric. Carsten K. Hey guys, would like to make a rain I believe that both are polyester, which give significantly less strech than silnylon, and better UV resistance. any body interested to discuss the virtues positive and negative of silnylon and silpoly? Mar 1, 2015 · I already bought a bunch of the 20D Silpoly XL to build a tipi with. Jul 31, 2017 · It seems to me that silpoly was/is the new lightweight preferred fabric for shelters/tarps with your PU4000 option as well. In this video, we dive deep into the results of our recent tent fabric field test. We left these tents out for months to see get a good idea of how weather and sun effects the durability of these fabrics. Whether you're an avid backpacker, camper, or outdoor enthusiast, choosing Silnylon for snow Silpoly for 3-season with an emphasis on pack ability. I would say that should be enough testament to its quality. Less prone to misting), but others may correct me. You cannot find a good tent made with DCF upper and a silnylon floor, unless you go to a component (modular) system. Of those three, I choose silpoly. Silnylon it better at dealing with tears, but they can both tear. Never had an issue with the quest for durability, and I don't have any reason to think the thunderfly will be any different in that regard. 1 ounces per square yard. Maybe I'll just wait for a few months to see if anything comes out in the meantime. 93 oz 15d Membrane Silpoly or the 1. You can seam seal this shelter yourself in about 30 minutes with the supplied seam sealer OR as an extra service we can do it for you! Peel-and-Stick – No sewing skills or heat required; simply cut to desired size, remove backing and apply to surface with pressure Durable – Silicone-based adhesive bonds to outdoor fabrics including silnylon, silpoly nylon, and vinyl (only silicone sticks to silicone) Compatible – Made of ripstop nylon that’s sheer enough to match Silpoly doesn't sag/stretch like silnylon. Oct 19, 2024 · SilPoly vs SilNylon. 15D membrane (0. And, I think that Silnylon is better for the job I want it to do. Mar 15, 2020 · Here we take a peek at some Silnylon, Silpoly and Dyneema Fiber (cuben fiber) tarps stuffed in the stuff sacks to see the sizes. They’re also very hard to get a perfect pitch with if you’re spatially challenged 🥺 and they are so bulky. Unlike traditional materials, such as silnylon and silpoly tents, Dyneema, or DCF (Dyneema Composite Fabric), offers unparalleled durability and lightweight properties. You will find that nearly every cottage vendor is using 20D Silpoly as the standard material on their products. 51. It’s winter down here which means daily rain and long nights, I’m quite impressed. 4 oz finished). High stress tends to grind sand into the interior sides of the slider instead of giving the malleable teeth the opportunity to bend around the grains. Trying to decide whether to go with the lighter . I've used an X-Mid Pro 2 for more than a year. Also scrap the eno. This fabric is woven and coated, not laminated. I wouldn’t do a silnylon, from what I’ve heard the time they take to dry out even from (frequent) condensation is ugh. But I know silnylon is great for snow DCF for 3 season and the lightest weight possible with a trade off being it’s not packable. Nov 10, 2023 · OT: Eigentlich wollte ich ja mal eine Pyramide aus Silpoly nähen, für den Einsatz im Fjell, aber nach dem Erlebnis von @Mia im Zeltwird es wohl eins aus 55g Silnylon - Wasseraufnahme hin oder her. silpoly, pros and cons question. It's a silnylon design. It's extremely lightweight but it's also very susceptible to punctures and it also doesn't pack down nearly as small as an equivalent size silpoly tarp. Silpoly is much more desirable as it doesn't sag when wet/cold. It is a bit weird how slippery it is, especially when trying to stuff it in a stuff sack. DCF is definitely sticky, i've noticed that too. Meanwhile silpoly is less than 1/2 of the price and DCF is a pain to have to fold every time you want to put it away, plus it takes up a lot more room than Dyneema DCF Vs Silnylon. Grumspiff. Just tighten up the tent before you go to sleep for the night. Whereas the heaviest silnylon is 1. SilPoly is "lighter, tighter, can handle an all-nighter" (when raining) - as well as UV resistant. I’m not sure how much time that saves in practice but may be important to some. 7D MTN 6. I've been using a MEMBRANE silpoly winter tarp for just over 3 years (mixed use since I also use my hex and asym depending on weather). Only thru hikers rival my outdoor time. 5oz for 40d. I have not seen a thread discussing the advantage/disadvantages between these fabrics. It’d be difficult to say which is the best fabric to make tents with because fabric quality varies widely depending on the manufacturer and Feb 23, 2023 · Aussi l’arrivée du silpoly sur le marché des tentes et autres abris de bivouac n’est-elle pas passée inaperçue. I can get SilNylon for $4. Jan 2, 2021 · With the advent of improved polyester tent fabrics and coatings, a superlight silpoly tent should be within reach for MYOG. I wish I had waited before buying the Silpoly. View Profile View Forum Posts SilNylon. 12. Oct 10, 2016 · Both SilPoly and SilNylon have a lot of variations. In the case of UltraTNT, that looks like two polyester films sandwiching a grid of Ultra (or ultra-high-molecular-weight polyethylene) fibers. My plan is to get an 11 foot Superfly. Well, I got an email saying that they now have "1. Silnylon and Silpoly options are available for all Minifly ultralight tarp camo and color options. 8'x9') - Xenon 20d ripstop silpoly is low stretch and doesn't sag in the rain - Flat tarps provide nearly unlimited different set-up options - Ties outs at each corner and at mid-points, 8 total - Bivy mitten hooks at ridge ends When given a choice between 1. I have read to store in a sil nylon bag, which is slippery and less abrasive than DCF. Apr 22, 2016 · Cuben’s out of the question due to price. Warbonnet's silpoly holds up fine in the winter and is the superior option. 8 DCF holds up considerably better and longer than . DCF (und Ultra) kann man gut abwischen, allerdings funktioniert das mit einem feuchten Lappen nur mäßig gut. I prefer a silnylon floor because I CAN repair it. For the same reason, silpoly performs worlds better in snow and freezing rain. Some show normal variation; others are actually inferior. Packa (not designed as a tarp) comes in 10D, 20D (standard), and 30D silnylon. We’ve had excellent long term durability results from our 30d Silnylon. 7oz or so pole jack required for cricket Dec 2, 2012 · With a good silpoly, there isn't a big strength difference (nothing like accountant vs elite athlete). My question is regarding silnylon vs silpoly; im curious how much better is the silpoly is it worth the upgrade? Does the sag on impregnated sil nylon really impact the performance? My YE bonus is coming in and im hoping to purchase myself an upgrade for this up coming season, I can afford either one however im not sure whats a gimic and whats DCF and I’m guessing Silpoly dry out more quickly than Silnylon. I make all my tunnels with silnylon. My wondering is that 30D might be worth the weight penalty, as silpoly is already more vulnerable than silnylon of equal weight/denier. 74 to . The design does not permit any sag, even when wet. 5' silnylon tarp that I adore because it is so packable. 3oz Large- 5. While we recognize silpoly’s advantage like minimal sag in rain and decent UV resistance, we find that silnylon’s elasticity gives our tents a critical edge in windy or turbulent weather. Dec 13, 2020 · Cuben Fiber vs Silnylon vs Silpoly Vor- und Nachteile des jeweiligen Materials für Zelte und Tarps. 50 at Ripstop By the Roll. Jun 12, 2020 · If your silpoly is really pure sil then you can use the normal silnylon methods, but a lot of silpoly is really sil/pu poly where the coating can be (1) a blend, or (2) different on each side. My winter tent has taken 100 kph snow storm all night on a ridge and been happy. The question is 30D Silnylon or 20D Silpoly? The silpoly is an ounce lighter (18 oz. 1 oz vs $100 on the 2p. But , depending, I do more camping in a year than most. Dec 14, 2023 · On the silpoly vs silnylon issue I’ve been chatting with Mike at The Tent Lab – a very experienced trade designer of hiking tents as you know. 5: Some/Most of the 20d silpoly and 20d silnylon availble to DYI’ers though resellers are not as good as the ones used by some tent manufacturers. 24 oz 20d Silnylon. With silnylon shelters you need to use catenary curve cuts along straight edges to get a taught pitch. g. Rated 5 out of 5. Dcf tents are very light. I made a tipi [12. Jan 10, 2020 · It is further improved by an additional waterproof coating. 0 oz | 28 gm. 5oz Cuben fiber. Our SilNylon is a 30D Ripstop Nylon 6. poncho, 108″ x 59″. 6oz silpoly [durable, good but heavier] and the higher quality Silnylon 30D which I consider the best all around fabric for the smaller 2-4 man shelters. SilNylon is stronger (but by how much I do not know). e. The silnylon takes ~2 hours to dry out unless its a really hot day with direct sun. shaped tarp – similar to 4 yard shelter. Probably the reverse. This flexibility, similar to a boat’s anchor line, helps absorb shock from strong gusts without straining the fabric, seams, or stakes. 6. 93 oz membrane Silpoly would be worth it, but not for a poncho tarp. 2020. Polyester is the best choice for a higher waterproof rating, but if that is not an issue, silnylon is lighter, stronger and stretchier. And don’t see what the slippery quality of silpoly has to do with it. I'd only use the 7D nylon for a summer "just in case" tarp, but in that context it's the best and I wouldn't use DCF in its place anymore (I have made DCF and 7D summer tarps). Sewing Sil-Nylon is a test of patience. They’re also roughly comparable in price. 19 oz. 1 oz silnylon or silpoly. Mar 1, 2023 · Silnylon: Short for silicone-coated nylon, the most common fabric for tents and stuff sacks. I got rid of mine for a silpoly lunar solo. A dry tent which is pitched nice and tight will be slack and sagging after it gets rained on. But given that silpoly has the better UV resistance, there’s no reason to believe that it would fail quicker than silpoly. One of its reputed benefits vs silnylon is that it does not stretch and sag when wetted. It did have more sunlight on it than the silnylon tarp 3) DCF is ultralight, waterproof, and strong for it's weight but it is neither silpoly or silnylon strong. Mar 29, 2006 · Je vais donc partir sur du 40D mais j'hésite entre le silnylon 40D et le silpoly 40D. Also weigh them and hang a couple to compare. Also the fabric stays more dry than silnylon after rain. The silpoly did not hold up as well, it leaked (misted) way more than the nylon, and the real amount of 'sag' was rather minimal. Oct 14, 2014 · As it's been said, Sil-Nylon is impregnated with silicone. 2. I'm having a surprisingly difficult time actually finding good hydrostatic head measurements of either. Like silnylon is more prone to needing readjustment after setting up/getting wet. In addition, you’ll learn about the most common ultralight fabrics used in these shelters, including Dyneema Composite Fabrics, silpoly, and silnylon – and how these fabrics differ in terms of their performance. (verified owner) It is quite strange that you only save 3oz going with DCF. I've recently been doing a fair amount of MN winter camping with my trusty MJ tarp, which I lovebut last weekend it was SUPER windy and although my MJ held strong, I've decided I want a tarp with doors for added protection from the cold winter wind. Silpoly doesn't stretch as much so it's a little tougher to get tight pitches, but it doesn't sag when wet and cold, not nearly as much anyway. Main downside is its expense. reagierte darauf May 12, 2023 · Per usual the savvy Britons over on trek-lite. I got a very light silpoly for a tarp that I use with hammocking and as a ground family tarp, because I'm never, ever going to test it in a very windy situation. It also doesn't absorb water (wet out) like silnylon. When you’re packing for a trek, every ounce counts, and DCF’s ability to lighten your load without sacrificing strength is a game-changer. 6, have a pressure rating several times that of the stock American silnylon, and are slightly lighter than stock silnylon. Nov 11, 2023 · Please support the creative cottage companies who shoulder the risk in creating new designs. 94 oz/sqyd while the lightest silnylon usually comes in over 1. the 14oz cricket swelled up to 22oz when wet and took an entire day or more to dry. As you surely know, most frequently used material for coating is polyurethane. Cuben Fiber vs Silnylon vs Silpoly. But this type has some downsides, so ultralight advanced tents that are designed to be carried on the trail sometimes Apr 17, 2023 · Silpoly and Silnylon are two types of fabrics used for outdoor gear. Show Printable Version; 10-28-2018, 19:46 #1. 5 oz vs $90 on the 1p, or 2. Sag does happen on the silnylon, but it's never been something I can't work around. 6 with Sil/Sil coating (they claim 3000 mm HH). sag, most silpoly I've seen has a higher HH). If the poly turns out to be less abrasion resistant for whatever reason; then it’s back to silnylon. Silpoly. I don’t like the sag-when-wet from nylon, therefore decided to go with silpoly. silpoly: So, what's the big difference anyway? Silpoly has become tremendously popular mainly because it stays taut under load. However, this gear isn’t ultra-light, thus enter SilNylon. I would have to reccomend a sil-nylon poncho as the ultimate, ultralight raingear. Jul 22, 2024 · The ripping in wind was interesting. Part of this is done already by keeping tension on the corners of the floor, but think the poly would also help to prevent slipping and bunching up. . Thread starter nednic; Start date Apr 13, 2021; Apr 13, 2021 #1 nednic FNG. It's so so so much better at shedding water than silnylon in my experience -- you don't get any of the misting at all. Dec 10, 2019 · rclouse79 - In response to your questions/comments on silnylon vs silpoly Silnylon stretches, especially after it gets wet. Also, Silpoly isn't that new. 5 osy finished) 30D MTN Silnylon 6. Color is a BIG factor. Merino vs Synthetic vs Cotton. Chad H. May 18, 2021 · As for the demerits of silpoly vs silnylon bonding, I’d need to see someone post some evidence of that. 9oz silnylon [excellent but heavier], the standard cheap silnylon 20D [OK], the 15D silnylon [ too light for a mountain hunt], the 1. Ripstopbytheroll finished weights. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Silnylon is more durable than DCF, which is reported to last 200 nights or so, perhaps more if it is stored correctly. Vor- und Nachteile des jeweiligen Materials für Zelte und Tarps. 🤔 I’d probably go woven/silnylon floor, but I also haven’t gone pro yet due to not being able to justify coughing up the $ for DCF. All my tarps look like a shanty town, never got them taut. It is generally believed that nylon is not as resistant to UV as polyester, but according to our tests, polyester is only slightly stronger than nylon, unless the fabric is thickened, no 15D material of the same thickness will last 90 days continuously under After owning both, I prefer sil nylon. X-mids are the other popular option obvs. Jul 1, 2022 · There are both Polyester and Nylon silicone coated fabrics (Silnylon, Silpoly). Warbonnet says the silpoly stretches less than the nylon but, the silnylon is more durable. 50/yard. 6oz and 1. Seems like a pretty robust option. It's bulkier, and harder to pack. 0oz Cuben fiber is listed at 3. 4oz. I don't believe it'll ever last as long as silpoly or silnylon either, it'll depend on how you prioritize weight vs volume and gear longevity vs price in the end imo. What about silnylon? Of course one could make a good case for silnylon, but as far as I can tell, silpoly does everything that silnylon can do, but has added advantages that nylon doesn't have (e. MLD comes with a sil bag already. 61/yd. Silpoly Vs. I used the stronger 1. I've used a HG quest, which is 20D silpoly, for years and just got a silpoly thunderfly that I've used on one trip now. Regarding packability, most of the time a pure Silicone coated fabric will be better at packing. Choosing between Dyneema and Silpoly, or even considering Silnylon vs DCF tents, requires a careful evaluation of these It's going to boil down to a weight vs. But for the true ultralight purists, silnylon still reigns supreme, with 10-denier options that are lighter than any silpoly on the market. Oct 29, 2020 · 2) the silpoly took a beating and worked like a charm. 2 minutes read. While this is relatively new to the tent market, it picks up where silnylon left off and adds some property improvements. Jan 13, 2025 · The LightHeart Gear Rain Jacket (MSRP $150) is a lightweight siliconized polyester (silpoly) waterproof rain jacket made the old-fashioned way, without any so-called waterproof/breathable fabric. Both are on sale until tomorrow for Roughtly 6oz for DCF vs 10-11oz for Silpoly of the same size as a percentage it seems like a big difference but either one is going to take a respectable chunk out of your BPW vs a tent. Brilliant on Henry’s part to offer both fly options, TT’s IG page mentions 30D silnylon being a better choice for “higher elevations or shoulder season”. Dec 25, 2022 #12 sndmn11 "DADDY" Joined Tents made with Silpoly, Silnylon, and PU coated silnylon are much less expensive than Dyneema because they can be sewn using conventional methods. Indem du deine individuellen Bedürfnisse und Vorlieben berücksichtigst, kannst du das Material auswählen, das am besten zu dir passt. 1oz MTN Silnylon 6. The SilPoly version of this shelter requires seam sealing, which is why we include seam sealer with all our SilPoly and SilNylon shelters. Sil nylon stretches ( a bit ) , sags ( a bit ) , and will absorb a tiny TINY bit of water. Both materials have excellent durability and strength, making them popular choices for camping tents, backpacks Mar 6, 2022 · In my opinion, sliders tend to wear out much more quickly on DCF tents than on silnylon or silpoly tents because DCF tents are high tension and therefore put a ton of stress on the zipper. This would mean that silpoly is a bit more waterproof (I. Overall, the best all purpose materials (in my opinion) are either plain 1. The following information refers to the Silnylon that we formerly offered. But a light colored silpoly vs a darker nylon--well, the nylon will fare better. com were the first to be on top of this latest development. It's not as touch as poly. Please note that we are not currently using Silnylon. Jan 19, 2019 · Is the difference between silnylon vs silpoly important enough to be a deciding factor in shelter selection? I've been in the market for a new flat tarp and possibly a mid tent, so all of the sudden I've been reading up and nearly convincing myself that I need a silpoly shelter - but I don't want to fall for a fad. Silpoly doesn't soak up much water and has solid UV resistance. In his view the lower stretch of silpoly in the wet is a game-changing advantage vs silnylon 6. SilPoly: Short for silicone-coated polyester; similar to silnylon but not used as often. Feb 6, 2021 · Obviously, if one or the other fabric needs replaced more often, that might more than offset any differences in production. Jan 22, 2025 · It also has zero stretch, which makes it easy to get a good tight pitch, but will also stress stakes, stake loops, and poles more than a silnylon in heavy wind due to the shock absorbing stretch that silnylon has. 1 silpoly, what are the pros and cons of one over the other? 10-28-2018, 19:48. We slept well. My hex tarp is silpoly 1. Oct 15, 2023 · Silnylon Vs Silpoly Vs Dyneema. Silnylon vs. 6oz Extra Large: 6oz. View Profile View Forum Posts Dec 13, 2020 · Advantages and disadvantages of each material for tents and tarps - Silnylon is often used as the main material for tents. It's easy to repair with T-Tape though. May 6, 2014 · Silnylon is stronger and doesn't tear as easily. Dec 24, 2022 · Now I’m going down the silnylon vs silpoly rabbit hole. 6: No one on any forum hardly ever talks about dry stretch on the bias. Look at warbonnet, hammock gear, dutchware, etc for tarps. The only real difference I can tell is that xenon lists a hydrostatic head of 1000' while silpoly, I believe, is 1500. I think we need to know more about the composition of the coatings on these fabrics and the effects of the use of polyurethane, which has been used for eons. Check stock for details. UV slowly destroys the material and soaks up more water. It's lighter and packs down very well. Dec 2, 2022 · But am considering silpoly for the next floor in order to keep the fabric flat and stable. Sent from my Bonding Silpoly / Silnylon tarp If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. 5 DCF the tarp is 176g and $325. it's also more fragile, so while holding up into the wind is mostly dependent on how you orient it towards the wind and how it's tie-outs and stakes are set, another consideration is things falling from the wind (like sticks, pine cones, etc) can be a threat to punch through the material. Oct 14, 2021 · Naturehike Opalus 2 Tent – silnylon design. Weight: Medium- 5. 6 XL". Ein äußerst interessantes Experiment. Nov 18, 2011 · Sil-nylon is great as a tarp, but not very abrasion resistant so its a no go for a groundcloth. ). Since we've used it in CO and WY several more times with no problems. Show Printable Version; 11-11-2018, 14:36 #11. 6 is stronger than the more common Jun 29, 2024 · Ich habe Zelte aus DCF, Silnylon und Silpoly benutzt. The 20D Silpoly is the standard 1. It's very slippery when placed against itself. Gatewood Cape uses 30D silnylon. It's $12. I do distain the slipperyness of silnylon, but spending an extra $50 to get a floor with a far shorter lifespan is just not an efficient way to save 1 oz. Even economics are against it. I pitched the Yama silpoly flat tarp and my MLD cat-cut silnylon tarp in A-frame configurations, allowed them to stretch a bit while dry, re-tightened their guylines, then measured their mid-panel heights. A ce que j'ai compris, le silnylon a une moins bonne résistances aux UV et à également l'avantage de moins s'affaisser sous la pluie et le vent. DCF does not like that! I started to see tiny holes in mine after a year. Realise also that knockoffs using different material — say, silnylon vs silpoly or DCF — often perform less well than the original because the latter is designed around specific strength and stretch parameters. But would be curious to hear others’ thought process. Both are Sil/PU double coated with a 1500 mm. And yes, I do say Dyneema cuben fiber several times. EP. In . My perspective as the owner of LightHeart Gear - we went back to silnylon after a round of silpoly tents . Jun 5, 2023 · Silpoly is a relatively new shelter material. Silpoly might actually be ok for snow, I don’t know. If it was just a tarp, maybe the 15D 0. 2). Jun 21, 2022 · Did note that RBTR silpoly has significantly less bias stretch than silnylon; but that could be from the polyester vs the nylon. 0 oz/sqyd and is not nearly as MLD PRO SILPOLY SEAM SEALING. Would it be correct to say that 40d silnylon is better for dry, sandy environments because it has a higher abrasion resistance, but 20d silpoly is better for wet climates because it doesn't absorb water and doesn't sag in the rain? Nov 14, 2018 · Thread: silnylon vs. The design allows for maximum mechanical ventilation, and you never have to worry about ”wetting out” or waterproof coatings failing. How does this new MTN silnylon compare against the silpoly and pu coated silpoly in terms of strength, stretch, water absorption, etc? Ron from MLD suggests his new pro silnylon has far less stretch than previous silnylon. When given a choice between 1. qohf uymo wuerbj kyzlpf xxiq czwpv wtgkzk yhgzxn mvtox zifmu